2003 AIPMT The Living WorldBiological Species Concept Hard Question 1 of 2 in Biological Species Concept

Nicotiana sylvestris flowers only during long days and N. tabacum flowers only during short days. If raised in the laboratory under different photoperiods, they can be induced to flower at the same time and can be cross-fertilized to produce self-fertile offspring. What is the best reason for considering N. sylvestris and N. tabacum to be separate species : -

A They cannot interbreed in nature
B They are reproductively distinct
C They are physiologically distinct
D They are morphologically distinct

The answer is A.

Solution

According to the biological species concept (Mayr), a species is a group of natural populations that actually or potentially interbreed in nature and are reproductively isolated from other such groups.
In nature, N. sylvestris flowers only in long days and N. tabacum only in short days. Since they never flower at the same time, they cannot cross-pollinate in nature (temporal or seasonal isolation, a prezygotic barrier).
The fact that they can be crossed in the laboratory under artificial photoperiods does not matter, because they do not interbreed under natural conditions.
So the best reason for considering them separate species is that they cannot interbreed in nature.

Concept Reproductive isolation in nature

Biological Species Concept in past papers

2 questions from this chapter have appeared across 2 exam years.